✓ verbatim from the press ≈ paraphrased
Justice Gilmar Mendes requested an extended review this Thursday (28) and suspended the virtual trial at the STF analyzing the constitutionality of Clean Slate Law changes approved by Congress in 2025. The senior justice will have up to 90 days to return the case to the plenary for continued analysis. ✓
Press quotes (1)
"O ministro Gilmar Mendes pediu vista nesta quinta-feira (28) e suspendeu o julgamento no STF que discute a constitucionalidade das mudanças na Lei da Ficha Limpa aprovadas pelo Congresso Nacional no ano passado. Com o pedido, o decano da Corte terá até 90 dias para devolver o processo para análise do plenário."
Until the interruption, the vote was 2-0 for partial suspension of changes made by Complementary Law 219/2025. Rapporteur Cármen Lúcia and Justice Luiz Fux voted against changes that shorten ineligibility periods for convicted politicians. Eight justices had yet to vote. ✓
Press quotes (1)
"Até a interrupção do julgamento, o placar era de 2 votos a 0 pela suspensão parcial das alterações promovidas pela Lei Complementar 219/2025. A relatora do caso, ministra Cármen Lúcia, foi acompanhada pelo ministro Luiz Fux."
The action (ADI 7881) was filed by Rede Sustentabilidade challenging changes to ineligibility period calculation criteria. The alterations make the eight-year period count from conviction by collegiate body, rather than after serving the sentence as currently occurs. The new legislation also created a 12-year maximum limit for cumulative electoral punishments from successive convictions. ≈
Press quotes (1)
"A ação apresentada pela executiva nacional da Rede Sustentabilidade questiona mudanças feitas pelo Congresso na Lei da Ficha Limpa, especialmente nos critérios de contagem do prazo de inelegibilidade de políticos condenados ou cassados. Processo: ADI 7881"
According to Cármen Lúcia, part of the changes were approved irregularly in the legislative process, with the Senate altering the proposal's merit without the text returning for new Chamber analysis. The justice classified the alterations as a "setback" in guarantees established by the Clean Slate Law, created 17 years ago through popular initiative. ≈
Press quotes (1)
"No julgamento, Cármen Lúcia afirmou que parte das mudanças foi aprovada com irregularidade no processo legislativo. Segundo a ministra, o Senado alterou o mérito da proposição legislativa em seu mérito sem que o texto retornasse para nova análise da Câmara dos Deputados."
Gilmar Mendes' vista request suspends judgment for up to 90 days
Score was 2-0 against alterations when interrupted
Covered by only some sources, or where the accounts diverge.
Covered by only some sources (2)
Decision could benefit specific politicians like Eduardo Cunha, Sérgio Cabral and Anthony Garotinho
Cármen Lúcia considered the alterations a 'setback'
-
What is the PGR's specific position on each contested provision?
Why it's still unknown: Sources mention that the PGR positioned for invalidation of only specific excerpts, but don't detail which provisions
Did not cover: Band Congressoemfoco -
What is Justice Gilmar Mendes' history of vista requests in Clean Slate Law cases?
Why it's still unknown: No source analyzes whether there's a previous pattern of vista in similar cases that would allow interpreting the strategic timing
Did not cover: Band Congressoemfoco -
Was a majority formed before the vista request?
Why it's still unknown: Sources don't indicate whether other justices had already signaled position or if the vista request interrupted majority formation
Did not cover: Band Congressoemfoco -
What is the suspension's impact on 2026 electoral deadlines?
Why it's still unknown: Sources don't analyze whether the up to 90-day delay affects candidacy registration timeline for municipal elections
Did not cover: Band Congressoemfoco