✓ verbatim from the press ≈ paraphrased ◦ composed from multiple sources
Supreme Court Justice Cármen Lúcia criticized the decision granting judicial pardon to Monique Medeiros, mother of young Henry Borel, stating that "gender is not a free pass for committing crimes." In an interview with GloboNews' POD_i podcast on Monday, the justice questioned the lack of clarity in the reasoning behind the sentence issued by Judge Elizabeth Machado Louro. ≈
Press quotes (1)
"Gênero não é salvo-conduto para a prática de crime", diz Cármen Lúcia sobre perdão a Monique"
The judicial pardon was granted after the Rio de Janeiro Jury Court convicted Monique of torture by omission in Henry's death, which occurred in March 2021. The case was processed under number 03313777320218190001 in the II Jury Court. Judge Elizabeth Machado Louro justified the pardon alleging that Monique suffered a "disproportionate social reaction," classifying it as discriminatory and the result of a culture that demands women be "perfect mothers." ◦
Press quotes (2)
"Processo 03313777320218190001"
"Ao aplicar o perdão judicial, a juíza Elizabeth Machado Louro justificou que Monique já sofreu um castigo severo o suficiente. A magistrada criticou a "reação desproporcional da sociedade", classificando-a como discriminatória e fruto de uma cultura que exige que a mulher seja uma "mãe perfeita"."
Cármen Lúcia countered this reasoning, emphasizing that judicial pardon "exists in cases provided by law, has nothing to do with misogyny." The justice highlighted that the fight for gender equality seeks equal rights and responsibilities, not privileges or exemption from punishment. "What cannot be used is something legitimate, which is fighting for equal rights, with the mistaken view that society gets that defending women leads to exemption," she declared. ✓
Press quotes (2)
"O perdão judicial existe nos casos previstos em lei, não tem nada a ver com misoginia, nada"
"O que não se pode usar é algo legítimo, que é lutar pela igualdade de direitos, com a visão equivocada que fica para a sociedade de que a defesa das mulheres leva a uma isenção para que elas possam, ou a uma impermeabilidade à resposta do direito na prática de qualquer ilícito"
The decision generated strong repercussion because Monique was convicted and immediately pardoned, without clear pedagogical explanation to society, according to the justice. The Rio de Janeiro Public Prosecutor's Office and the defense of Leniel Borel, Henry's father, have already announced appeals against the decision. Former city councilman Jairo Souza Santos Júnior, the child's stepfather, was sentenced to more than 60 years in prison for the crimes. ✓
Press quotes (2)
"Como é que alguém que foi condenada imediatamente é perdoada?"
"O Ministério Público do Rio de Janeiro e a defesa de Leniel Borel, pai de Henry, já informaram que recorrerão da decisão"
Cármen Lúcia declared not knowing the full text of Judge Elizabeth Louro's sentence
The justice emphasized that high-impact decisions need clear explanation to society
Covered by only some sources, or where the accounts diverge.
Covered by only some sources (2)
Jairo Souza Santos Júnior was sentenced to 64 years and 8 months in prison for triple-qualified homicide, torture, coercion in legal proceedings, procedural fraud and ideological falsification
The judge argued that if it were the father in the same situation, he probably wouldn't even have been prosecuted
-
What is the full text of the judicial pardon sentence issued by Judge Elizabeth Machado Louro?
Why it's still unknown: Justice Cármen Lúcia herself declared not knowing the full sentence, and access to the complete case files of TJ-RJ process 03313777320218190001 was not obtained
-
What are the STF jurisprudential precedents on applying judicial pardon in crimes against children?
Why it's still unknown: The doctrinal discussion about when judicial pardon applies and how higher courts evaluate gender issues in criminal sentencing was not mapped in the coverage
-
What is the formal position of the STF or other justices on gender-based reasoning in criminal decisions?
Why it's still unknown: Cármen Lúcia's comments were made in a personal interview, but there is no record of the court's institutional position on the topic